The Vacation Rental Industry Has More Power Than It Realizes. It's Time to Start Using It.

8:00
Why petitions and boycotts won't solve OTA dependence—and how owners and managers can create meaningful, lasting change.
Every time a major online travel agency (OTA) announces another policy change, the vacation rental industry seems to go through the same cycle.
Owners and managers express frustration. Industry groups voice concerns. Social media fills with complaints. Someone starts a petition. Someone else proposes a boycott.
And then what happens?
A few weeks later, most everyone goes back to business as usual, operating under the very policies they were protesting.
I understand the frustration. I've spent more than two decades in real estate and property management, and I've seen firsthand how outside companies, changing regulations, and shifting markets can affect the businesses we work so hard to build.
But I think we're approaching this problem from the wrong direction.
The real issue isn't that Airbnb keeps changing its rules. It's that so many owners and managers have built businesses that depend on Airbnb's rules.
And until we address that underlying problem, we'll keep having the same arguments.
Airbnb Isn't Responsible for Your Business Strategy. You Are.
Let's establish something right away.
Airbnb is a business. So are Vrbo, Booking.com, Expedia, and every other distribution platform.
Their leadership has a responsibility to make decisions that benefit their companies, customers, and shareholders.
Sometimes those decisions benefit property owners and managers. Sometimes they don't.
We shouldn't be surprised by that.
What should concern us is how dependent our industry has become on businesses whose priorities we don't control, and which often do not align with ours.
For many vacation rental managers, the OTAs have become far more than distribution channels. They've effectively become the foundation of their entire marketing and revenue strategy.
That's a dangerous position for any business.
When one company controls a substantial portion of your bookings, guest communications, and access to customers, that company has tremendous influence over how you operate.
And the more dependent you become, the less flexibility you have when its policies change.
A distribution channel should support your business. It shouldn't dictate your business strategy.
That's one of the fundamental principles behind the Full Spectrum Approach we use at Legendary Consultants.
Revenue strategy, marketing, guest relationships, owner acquisition, operations, and technology should work together to build an independent, sustainable business.
No single platform should control the outcome.
Why Petitions and Short-Term Boycotts Rarely Create Lasting Change
I'm not opposed to people making their voices heard.
Petitions can bring attention to legitimate concerns. Boycotts can sometimes influence corporate behavior, particularly when participation is substantial and sustained.
But let's consider the practical realities of the vacation rental industry.
Suppose a few hundred or even a few thousand owners decide to temporarily remove their properties from Airbnb.
What happens if their competitors continue accepting bookings?
What happens when those owners need to generate revenue, pay mortgages, compensate employees, and meet their obligations to property owners?
How long can they realistically remain off the platform?
And what happens when the boycott ends?
Unless the underlying economic relationship changes, the platform retains much of the same influence it had before.
That's why I believe we need to think beyond individual protests.
If we can organize enough owners and managers to participate in a boycott, why can't we organize those same people to create lasting change?
That's the conversation I'd rather be having.
The Guest Identification Issue Is Bigger Than an OTA Policy
One of the current areas of disagreement involves guest information, identification, and the ability of property managers to communicate directly with the people occupying their properties.
This isn't simply a marketing issue.
It's also a matter of safety, security, fraud prevention, and accountability.
Consider the responsibilities of a professional property manager.
We're responsible for protecting an owner's investment, enforcing rental agreements, coordinating emergencies, addressing property damage, and maintaining reasonable safety standards.
Yet some booking platforms restrict how and when managers can collect guest information.
Airbnb has its own identity verification procedures, but those procedures don't necessarily give managers the information or independent verification they need to fulfill their responsibilities.
And that raises a fundamental question:
Why should the person responsible for operating and protecting a property have less ability to verify and communicate with its occupants than the platform that generated the booking?
Hotels routinely establish guest registration and identification procedures. Their exact legal obligations vary, but verifying the responsible guest's identity is a familiar part of hotel operations.
Why shouldn't short-term rentals have reasonable, consistent identification and accountability standards as well?
Whether someone stays three nights, ten nights, or thirty nights, the underlying safety concerns don't disappear. And the length of a stay can change the legal relationship entirely. In many jurisdictions, longer stays introduce different requirements involving occupancy, rental agreements, taxes, and potentially tenant protections.
Those rules vary by jurisdiction, but they illustrate an important point: property managers have legal and operational responsibilities that don't disappear simply because a reservation originated through an OTA.
Verification alone won't eliminate fraud, crime, or property damage. But a reasonable, secure verification process can be an important part of protecting guests, owners, managers, and surrounding communities.
And it should be possible to establish those standards while respecting guest privacy and protecting sensitive personal information.
Responsibility Without Authority Creates Another Risk
There's another consideration I believe our industry needs to take seriously: the potential for litigation.
When something goes wrong at a vacation rental, the legal consequences may extend beyond the individual responsible for the incident.
Depending on the circumstances, property owners, professional managers, and even homeowners associations may find themselves defending allegations that they failed to take reasonable precautions, enforce established requirements, or fulfill their legal responsibilities.
And there's an important distinction between ultimately being held liable and simply being named in a lawsuit. Even an unsuccessful claim can involve substantial legal expenses, insurance complications, time, and reputational damage.
But consider another potential vulnerability: inconsistent guest-verification procedures across booking channels.
Many managers accept reservations through their own websites, Airbnb, Vrbo, and other distribution channels.
For direct reservations, a manager might require identification verification, a signed rental agreement, and a documented guest-registration process. Yet some of those same procedures may be restricted, altered, or omitted when guests book through a particular OTA.
Now imagine a serious incident occurs.
An attorney examining the manager's practices might ask:
"You required these security and verification procedures for guests booking directly through your website. Why weren't those same precautions taken when the guest booked through another platform?"
And if the manager explains that the OTA handled verification, the next questions might be:
"What exactly did the platform verify? Did you know what its verification procedures involved? How did you determine those procedures were sufficient to protect the property and community?"
Those are uncomfortable questions, particularly when the manager's own policies suggest that certain precautions were important enough to require for other reservations.
Different verification procedures don't automatically constitute negligence, and platform restrictions don't automatically establish liability. But inconsistent practices could raise questions about whether reasonable precautions were taken and whether the manager had a defensible basis for those decisions.
Should the booking channel determine the level of safety and accountability a property owner, guest, or community receives?
I don't believe it should.
Managers may need different procedures to comply with different distribution platforms. But the underlying safety objectives should remain consistent, with appropriate documentation showing how applicable legal, contractual, and community obligations are being fulfilled. And those objectives must respect guest privacy, avoid unnecessary collection of sensitive information, and comply with the law.
Ultimately, this brings us back to the larger issue.
If owners, managers, and associations are expected to bear the operational and potential legal consequences, they should have a meaningful voice in establishing the standards under which their properties operate.
Those standards should be developed collectively, with appropriate legal guidance, rather than leaving individual operators to navigate conflicting requirements on their own.
We cannot reasonably separate responsibility from authority.
I've Seen What Local Authority Can Accomplish
This isn't just a theoretical argument for me.
During my years working in Arizona real estate and property management, I helped homeowners associations establish operating requirements for owners and management companies renting properties within their communities.
These requirements addressed issues such as guest identification, contact information, management accountability, and emergency communication.
The communities wanted to know who was occupying properties and how to contact the responsible parties when problems occurred.
These were legitimate concerns involving safety, security, and the rights of other residents.
Some managers resisted the requirements.
There were disputes and legal challenges.
But in the situations I worked with, the properly established and legally defensible rules were upheld, and managers who wanted to continue operating within those communities had to comply.
The important lesson wasn't that an HOA could establish any rule it wanted.
It was that lawfully established community operating requirements could be enforced, even when individual businesses didn't like them.
That experience changed how I view the current debate over OTA policies.
Instead of continually asking platforms to change their rules, why aren't we spending more time examining the lawful authority our communities already have to establish reasonable operating standards?
The Power of Local Laws and Community Standards
HOAs, municipalities, and state governments have different legal powers, and those powers vary by jurisdiction.
Not every proposed requirement will be enforceable. State preemption, existing governing documents, privacy protections, and other legal considerations all matter.
But within their lawful authority, communities can establish operating requirements that businesses must respect.
This is not unique to vacation rentals.
Businesses across numerous industries must adapt their operations to comply with local licensing, safety, registration, and other requirements.
Vacation rentals are no exception.
And there's an interesting detail in Airbnb's own policies: the company recognizes certain exceptions to its guest-information restrictions when additional information is required for legal or compliance reasons, including qualifying HOA rules and local laws. https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/4169?
Think about what that means.
The platform's general policies aren't necessarily the final word when an independently enforceable legal obligation applies. Airbnb's own policies recognize that applicable laws and documented community association requirements can create obligations beyond the platform's standard rules.
That distinction matters. It demonstrates that platform policies are not the only source of authority governing a vacation rental property.
That doesn't mean every HOA can compel Airbnb to change its systems or that every municipality can prohibit a booking platform. Those questions depend on the applicable law and the parties being regulated.
But it does demonstrate that legally sound local requirements can change what is permissible and required in a particular market.
Instead of fighting the same OTA policy every year, why not explore reasonable standards that apply regardless of which platform generates the booking?
Who Bears the Responsibility When Something Goes Wrong?
There's another question our industry should be asking.
If an owner, property manager, or community association can be held legally responsible for failing to take reasonable steps to protect a property and its occupants, should a booking platform have the authority to restrict those steps?
Depending on the circumstances and applicable law, owners, managers, and even homeowners associations may face civil liability when they fail to address foreseeable dangers or meet legally established safety obligations.
That doesn't mean every crime or incident creates liability, or that collecting identification guarantees safety.
But it does highlight a potential conflict between platform policies and the responsibilities of the people actually operating and overseeing these properties.
Who determines what constitutes reasonable guest verification?
Who is responsible for responding to an emergency?
Who establishes the standards for access to private communities and shared facilities?
And perhaps most importantly, who bears the consequences when those safeguards prove inadequate?
These aren't questions that should be answered by booking platforms alone.
They deserve thoughtful consideration by property owners, professional managers, community associations, legal professionals, and the communities affected by vacation rental operations.
And they reinforce why our industry needs reasonable, legally defensible standards developed through cooperation rather than relying exclusively on the changing policies of individual distribution platforms.
The Industry Has More Collective Influence Than It Realizes
Now consider the bigger picture.
Vacation rental owners and managers collectively represent an enormous number of properties, businesses, jobs, and local economic relationships.
They employ housekeepers, maintenance technicians, contractors, reservation agents, and hospitality professionals.
They support local restaurants, attractions, service providers, and tourism economies.
And they're homeowners, business owners, taxpayers, and constituents in the communities where they operate.
That's a substantial amount of collective influence.
Yet much of that influence remains fragmented.
One manager fights a regulation in one city.
Another fights an OTA policy in another state.
An association organizes a campaign somewhere else.
Often, they're addressing similar issues without a coordinated long-term strategy.
We already have local, regional, state, and national organizations representing parts of the vacation rental industry.
Organizations such as the Vacation Rental Management Association provide advocacy resources, legislative tracking, and support for local coalitions.
That's valuable work.
But I think we should be asking a larger question.
Are we coordinating these efforts effectively enough to establish the consistent, sustainable industry standards we need for the future?
And could existing associations accomplish even more by coordinating their efforts around a common framework while preserving their local independence?
Start Locally. Prove the Model. Then Expand.
I don't believe the solution begins by trying to organize the entire country overnight.
It begins in one community.
Bring together owners, professional managers, local associations, community representatives, and qualified legal counsel.
Identify a legitimate problem.
Develop reasonable standards that address that problem while protecting the interests of owners, guests, managers, and residents.
Make sure those standards are legally defensible, practical, and enforceable.
Then demonstrate that they work.
Once you have a successful model, introduce it to another community.
Then another.
As the model develops, neighboring cities and counties can share lessons, improve consistency, and coordinate their efforts.
Eventually, statewide associations may be able to support broader frameworks that account for differences in local conditions and state law.
And from there, national organizations can help share successful approaches across the industry.
This isn't about imposing identical regulations everywhere.
It's about developing consistent principles, professional standards, and coordinated representation that can be adapted to individual markets.
The goal should be stability and accountability, not unnecessary bureaucracy.
And that process should be led by the people who make up the heart of this industry. The property owners, professional managers, guests, and local communities who are directly affected by these decisions.
Industry standards should reflect the needs and responsibilities of those stakeholders, not be dictated primarily by whichever national booking platform controls the most reservations.
We Can Learn Something From the Real Estate Industry
I've also spent much of my career in residential real estate, including operating my own brokerage.
One thing that industry demonstrates is the influence that coordinated local associations and shared infrastructure can develop over time.
Local Realtor associations and multiple listing services helped establish professional networks, common practices, and shared business resources that became central to residential real estate.
That structure also created significant influence within the industry.
It wasn't built overnight, and its history includes legal disputes and legitimate questions about competition and access.
But the broader lesson is worth considering.
Organizations become more influential when they provide lasting practical value to their members, not simply when they ask those members to support a cause.
The vacation rental industry has its own associations and professional networks, but its distribution infrastructure is largely controlled by commercial platforms.
That presents both a challenge and an opportunity.
Could we develop stronger shared resources, greater cooperation, and more effective representation without sacrificing the independence of individual owners and managers?
I believe that's a discussion worth exploring.
And it may be one of the most important long-term conversations our industry needs to have.
This Isn't About Eliminating Airbnb
I want to be clear about something.
I'm not suggesting we should eliminate Airbnb, Vrbo, or any other OTA.
These platforms provide valuable distribution, technology, and access to travelers. They can be important components of a successful vacation rental business.
The problem isn't that these companies exist or that they pursue their own business interests.
The problem arises when owners and managers become so dependent on these platforms that they lose the ability to make independent strategic decisions, giving booking platforms disproportionate influence over how their properties and businesses operate.
A healthy industry needs competition, multiple distribution options, professional standards, and a reasonable balance of influence among its participants.
Owners and managers should be able to determine how their businesses operate within applicable laws, contractual obligations, and legitimate safety requirements.
Guests deserve transparency, security, privacy, and reliable service.
Communities deserve responsible operators who respect local requirements.
And booking platforms deserve the opportunity to compete and succeed while complying with the laws that apply to their operations.
Those interests don't have to be mutually exclusive.
It's Time to Change the Conversation
The next time Airbnb or another OTA announces a controversial policy, I'm sure we'll see more petitions, complaints, and calls for boycotts.
Some of those efforts may be justified.
But I'd like to see us begin asking different questions.
How do we reduce our dependence on individual platforms?
How do we establish reasonable safety and accountability standards?
How do we strengthen cooperation among independent owners, managers, and industry associations?
And how do we create an industry structure that provides greater stability and independence for the long term?
These are more difficult questions than deciding whether to sign a petition.
They require cooperation, planning, investment, and a willingness to look beyond immediate frustrations.
But they also offer the possibility of lasting solutions - solutions we help develop and implement rather than policies we're simply forced to react to.
The vacation rental industry doesn't lack power. It lacks the organization and coordinated strategy to use that power effectively.
And perhaps it's time we started changing that.
Because the future of our industry shouldn't be determined solely by whichever booking platform happens to control the most reservations.
It should be shaped by the people who own the properties, operate the businesses, serve the guests, and support the communities that make vacation rentals possible.
The question isn't whether we have the power to influence our industry's future. It's whether we're willing to organize and use it.
Legendary Consultants helps vacation rental management companies build stronger, more independent businesses through the Full Spectrum Approach - integrating revenue strategy, marketing, direct bookings, operations, owner relationships, and technology.
What do you think? Are industry petitions and boycotts enough, or is it time for a more coordinated, long-term approach? We'd love to hear your thoughts. You can reach us at https://www.legendaryreconsultants.com/contact
A Note About Legal Considerations
I am not an attorney, and this article is not intended to provide legal advice or legal opinions. The scenarios and questions discussed are presented for educational purposes and to encourage constructive industry dialogue - not to suggest that any particular company, platform, property manager, or association has violated the law or acted negligently.
Laws, legal responsibilities, and liability standards vary by jurisdiction and circumstance. Property owners, managers, and community associations should consult qualified legal counsel when evaluating their obligations, potential risks, and appropriate policies.
My purpose is simply to raise questions I believe our industry should be asking- and encourage us to work together to find responsible, practical solutions.



